Are hybrids or electric cars more reliable

The Drive and its partners may earn a commission if you purchase a product through one of our links. Read more.

If youve watched the Netflix documentary David Attenborough: A Life on Our Planet, youre likely researching everything you can do to help stave off the warming and destruction of our one and only home, Earth. Even if you havent seen it, hes the narrator of Planet Earth, so you get it. And while its the corporations that really need to enact, or be forced to enact, real change, reducing your carbon footprint is a good goal and one that can be done so by purchasing a hybrid car.

Hybrids have been around for more than 20 years, with the Toyota Prius ushering in the hybrid era for the masses. Although it didnt exactly make hybrids cool, it has and continues to help reduce humanitys impact on global greenhouse gas emissions, and that is a solid accolade. But what about the new hybrids? Or used hybrids? Which is most reliable? Which is better? What affects a hybrids reliability?

Never fear, reader, The Drivers info team has waded through the forums, read the NHTSA recall reports, and divined what really impacts a vehicles reliability and weve condensed that information into this very guide. Neat!

What Is a Hybrid Car?

A hybrid vehicle is one that uses two types of fuel and energy sources to achieve a singular goal of efficient propulsion. The most common type of hybrid vehicle blends a gasoline-powered combustion engine with one or more electric motors and a battery storage pack to achieve better fuel economy than a vehicle with only a combustion engine. Hybrids also use regenerative braking to return small amounts of electricity to their batteries.

Types of Hybrids

Just as there are multiple types of combustion engines, there are also multiple types of hybrid powertrains. Lets break it down into simple terms.

Mild Hybrid

On mild hybrids, the electric components are not capable of directly driving the wheels on their own. Instead, a small battery pack and electric motor act as assistants to help improve fuel economy, slightly increase performance with bursts of torque, regenerate energy, and power accessories. One of the most common jobs for an electric motor in a mild hybrid is to double as a starter and power the start-stop technology. More capable and efficient mild hybrids with 48-volt battery packs have recently proliferated throughout the industry.

Full Hybrid

A full hybrid car has electric components that can directly drive the wheels on their own, without the gas engine. Different types of full hybrids include parallel hybrids, series hybrids, and plug-in hybrids.

What Makes a Reliable Car Brand?

Reliability really depends on an ever-expanding bunch of variables, but the two biggest are a cars development and manufacturing. When car companies spend real resources producing a car, it tends to last. Carelessly designed, inadequately manufactured, and inexpensively assembled will produce something that likely wont stand the test of time.

Theres a work ethic component, too. Both Honda and Toyotas culture of reliability over profits has kept eachs legendary reliability at the forefront of the minds of consumers for decades. Heck, Lexus spent a decade and a half just to create the perfect paint! Add long warranties and phenomenal customer service, and its easy to see why theyve enjoyed their strong standings for as long as they have.

There are, however, outside factors that will impact a cars durability once you leave the lot.

What Can Impact a Cars Life?

The short answer? You, that giggly meat sack in the mirror. Your cars reliability and longevity are inseparably tied together with how you treat your ride. Do you take care of your vehicle, follow its maintenance schedule, and drive conservatively? Or do you drive like Lewis Hamilton and live in Siberia where winter will kill everything, including your will to live?

Regular maintenance such as oil changes, fluid flushes, tire rotation, and fuel system cleaners, as well as maintaining the cars exterior and interior will all extend your cars life. Youll also want to keep it away from harsh weather as much as possible.

Most importantly, however, is keeping your racecar driver driving to a bare minimum. By doing so, youll keep your engine, tires, brakes, and chassis happier and healthier for longer compared to if you treat every grocery run like its the Monte-Carlo Grand Prix. Stress is not only bad for you, its bad for your car.

What You Need to Look For When Buying a Used Hybrid

As with any transaction, there are a few key points that every customer should know and ask for before slapping your John Hancock on the dotted line. These helpful tips prevent you from purchasing a car that forces you to ask yourself, What have I done? What in Gods name have I done? How much is it to replace a hybrid system?! *sob-screaming continues.

Never fear, The Drives editors put together exactly what youll want to look for whenever you purchase a new or used hybrid. Ready?

Get its Service Records

A cars service records are its history. They should have everything from fluid flushes to if its had significant repairs. This is the cars life on paper and is really seen as how the last owner took care of it.

When your car comes with a stack of papers shoved neatly into its service book, youre likely not getting a lemon. But if all you have is one receipt from McDonalds, wed look elsewhere.

Obtain a CarFax

CarFax is a great tool. This little sheet of paper can tell you whether that car has undergone any major operations prompted by big-time accidents and tiny little fender-benders, or if it was recovered from the Atlantic Ocean after the ship that was carrying it capsized off the coast of Georgia.

Look for Rust

Whether youre buying from a cold-weather locale or the car has crisscrossed the country throughout its life, youre going to want to get down on your back and start looking for oxidation, otherwise known as rust. Do a thorough inspection because if you miss a patch of rust in the wheel well, youll likely have a front-row seat to your car slowly disappearing as if Thanos snapped it out of existence.

Look for Extreme Wear

Look, there are drivers out there, definitely not us, who think theyre Dominic Torreto. They drive their cars hard and put them away wet, both of which are not great for the cars overall health. Youll want to check the cars tires, work your way through its transmission, hit small speed bumps to check its suspension, and ask for an inspection by a trusted mechanic.

The 5 Most Reliable Hybrid Cars From the Past Ten Years

With that in mind, lets get into five of the most reliable hybrids of the last ten years as reported by J.D. Power, which ranks by consumer dependability reports. And oh yeah, the Toyota Prius is definitely one of them. Sorry, enthusiasts.

Toyota Prius

You cant deny the Prius power. It may look ugly, but with Toyota engineering and reliability, its a mix that cant be described as anything but attractive to your wallet.

Lexus NX 300h/Toyota RAV4 Hybrid

The Toyota RAV4 Hybrid and Lexus NX 300h share a platform, as well as a set of engines, one of which is a hybrid. Both received excellent feedback in J.D. Powers study, which isnt too surprising given Toyota has a penchant for long-lasting vehicles.

Lexus ES 300h/Toyota Avalon Hybrid

As with the NX 300h and RAV4 Hybrid, the ES 300h and Avalon Hybrid share a platform, a set of engines, and a few other details. That includes hybrid options for the two, which again, both received high marks in J.D. Powers study.

Honda Accord Hybrid

Hondas venerable Accord has been around since what feels like the dawn of time. And its maintained its car dominance since, with the hybrid offering even more for the customer. Not only do you get Hondas reliability, but also the benefit of fewer trips to the gas station.

Porsche Cayenne S E-hybrid

Teufel, ja! as the Germans say. Though you might be skeptical given the Porsche comes with a price tag of six figures, Porsches engineering is pretty legendary, and, apart from the IMS issue in the early 2000s, maintains excellent reliability.

FAQs About Hybrid Cars Reliability

Youve got questions, The Drive has answers!

Q. What Happens When You Run Out of Electricity in a Hybrid?

A. You keep driving! Thats the beauty of a hybrid, when your EV juice runs out, youve still got a tank of gas as a back up!

Q. What is the Best Hybrid Car for the Money?

A. If youre buying a new hybrid, and we cant believe were saying this, but the Toyota Prius is a helluva deal. And the man responsible for tuning its suspension has an 800 horsepower drift Supra, ensuring that it's actually pretty lively to boot. If youre looking for a used deal, the BMW i3 is great, funky, and reasonably priced.

Q. Ok, But Should I Buy a Hybrid Car?

A. Hybrid cars have come a long way since those early Prii. Outside a slightly higher initial cost, hybrids are great cars and will return better gas mileage, which keeps money in your pocket!

Q. Then Do Hybrid Cars Cost More to Maintain?

A. Not really. The only real extra cost in maintaining a hybrid is if the battery pack fails, and thats pretty rare.

Q. So Which Car Brands Last the Longest?

A. As weve stated, thats somewhat hard to discern, but Honda, Toyota, Hyundai, Kia, Acura, Lexus, and Ford all have reputations for dependability. There are some vehicles that are known to outlast others, i.e. the OG Toyota Land Cruiser, however, most car makers now offer consistent reliability and longevity.

Q. Yeah, But Whats the Worlds Most Reliable Car?

A. Buddy, its the one you take care of. Youre the biggest variable in your cars reliability by a long shot. Take care of your car and itll take care of you. That said, J.D. Power ranked the Lexus ES, which shares a chassis, engine lineup, and interior layout with Toyotas Avalon, as the most reliable car available. Both the Avalon and the ES are also available as hybrids.

Find Your Next Reliable Hybrid Car with Cars Direct

There are multiple available vehicles that will propel you in an environmentally friendly way, but how do you find a reliable one yourself? With Cars Direct, of course! The Drive has partnered with Cars Direct to help you find the perfect car for you to daily, reduce your gas bill, and not kill the environment! Win, win! Click here to get started.

Featured Products (H2)